Hello all,
I'm real confused. Clark's comments have engendered a wave of protest on sites like Kos and MyDD, as well as defenders.
I really don't understand what's so controversial about what he said.
First, let's be clear that there is a "swift-boat" style attack to be made here - that McCain only made it into Annapolis on his dad's coattails and other items such as the incident where his plane blew up while taking off. I've seen comments advocating this sort of approach, and I think it incredibly unwise - we do not need to go around demeaning McCain's service when he chose to refuse the chance to leave. Obama was playing word association when a reporter asked him about McCain. The word?
"Honorable."
Next is the tact that Clark used - that McCain served and served heroically, but that his time as a pilot, POW, and squadron leader doesn't contribute to his resume to be president - specifically, to his ability to make strategic and command decisions. Part of McCain's resume that he is putting forth to us the citizens is this military experience, and Clark is saying his time in the forces doesn't qualify him to be Commander in Chief.
Last, there is a strong view that Clark's words were out-of-bounds. Some said they were swift-boating, and others said they were inappropriate and played into McCain's hands. As God as my witness, I do not understand where this argument has a basis.
When Clark said that "Being shot down isn't a qualification to be President," you could hear Bob Schrieffer's surprise: "Really" was the word he used. Said Mika Brizinski: "But this is John McCain we're talking about."
I don't get it. Why is it high heresy to say that McCain's good character years ago doesn't qualify him to be President, when he was so wrong about Iraq? Why is this a "Third Rail," as Ben Smith said?\
Yes, he's sat on Armed Services forever. He's sent the budget over, and had hearings. But he hasn't ever been in the hotseat, and I don't understand why it seems to be sacrilege to suggest that he's more qualified in this area (especially for foreign relations) than Obama.
Help me out?
|
|
|
Permalink :: 11 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.